Should Tag and Chase Be Banned From Playground Activities?

Politics with a Liberal Bias


Blog For Free!


Archives
Home
2007 June
2007 May
2007 January
2006 December
2006 November
2006 October
2006 September
2006 August
2006 July
2006 June

My Links
Candidates on the Issues
Young Democrats of America
MoveOn.org
Alan Colmes
DNC.org
Air America
The New York Times
Reuters
9/11 Conspiracy Theory

tBlog
My Profile
Send tMail
My tFriends
My Images


Sponsored
Blog



US Deaths in Iraq since March 20th, 2003


Free JavaScripts provided
by The JavaScript Source

Proud D

Democrat History


Should Tag and Chase Be Banned From Playground Activities?
10.18.06 (10:51 am)   [edit]

Officials at an elementary school south of Boston have banned kids from playing tag, touch football and any other unsupervised chase game during recess for fear they'll get hurt and hold the school liable.  Recess is "a time when accidents can happen," said Willett Elementary School Principal Gaylene Heppe, who approved the ban.

On one hand, I do see where this principal is coming from.  As principal, she does have a responsibility to keeping her students safe from injury.  By not allowing this these playtime games to occur, this does decrease the risk of serious injury.

On the other hand, in today's society kids can no longer just be kids.  Playtime for kids is pertinent to their social development.  This is a great way for these kids to release stress, release energy and develop as human beings.

Which hand would pick?  This is starting to be strongly debated around the country.  If these principals do let their students play these playground games and one does get hurt, the parents are only going to want to sue.  I think the blame for this ban on playground games falls on the parents.  It is their fault.  If they wouldn't want to sue every time their kid got hurt and realize that kids will be kids and get hurt, then you wouldn't have to worry about this banning taking place.

I would have to agree with the principal here though.  If I was principal, I would have to approve the ban.  You're probably calling me a Pinco-commie liberal right now, but I'm looking at it from this point of view.  Schools are setup for on purpose and on purpose only.  Students are there to get an education.  They aren't there to teach religion, to discipline your kids, and not to allow them to run around unattended and get seriously injured.

I'm not against playtime fun.  The thing is that it needs to be supervised.  Allow the kids to play during their physical education class.  That is what that is there for.  Recess should be there so the kids should stretch their legs, go to the restroom, get some water, and give their brains a rest from all the strain.

 


posted by: inkspector (reply)
post date: 10.18.06 (11:20 am)

This is not uncommon. As you state, many schools have banned these sorts of games due to injuries to the students playing and the innocent bystanders that get hurt by the students playing with no care or concern for playground safety. Every school has playground rules and certified staff assigned to recess duty, but often times, there is so much going on on the playground, it is hard to keep an eye on everything all at one time.

For instance -- I am assigned a playground zone. Some kid trips and falls and is on the ground crying and I must tend to that one child while hundreds of others are around doing their thing. Once I go to the fallen kid (with a troop of kids following me) and start talking to him/her, I am missing other things going on in my zone: another kid gets hurt, or kids are fighting, or some kids are complaining another kid is not being nice or took something from them, you get the picture. It is busy and confusing and now I have a thick gathering of kids all around me that I can no longer really see my zone!

Most schools have one school nurse for several hundred students.
The school nurse not only nurses but also is an administrator in most schools responsible for recordkeeping and clerical work. This is a lot of work.

Some schools have even stopped allowing the kids to play in the am when they get off the bus because the school nurse is not on duty yet.

Another game banned because of too many broken bones, sprains, and strains is Red Rover.

We just got a new playground at school. The first week of school, some kid was not using the equipment properly, fell and broke his arm.
Because of that, the new piece of equipment was removed from the playground ruining it for so many others.

Some parents let their kids do anything at home, so they thing they can do the same at school and don't even think about putting everyone else at risk.

I do not miss recess duty at all.





posted by: tfruge1 (reply)
post date: 10.18.06 (11:43 am)

Reply to: inkspector
You make great points here. Understaffing is a major problem in schools like this but the problem is should schools really hire staff just to guard playgrounds? I don't think this will solve anything. The only way to keep every student safe on the playground would be have a person assigned to each and every kid and that just isn't plausible.

It is a shame that recess can't be what it used to be but because of the world we live in today, it just can't be. Nobody wants to take responsibility for anything anymore and parents are too quick to blame the school systems for their own mistakes. I think banning potentially harmful activities at recess is just something we are going to have to get used to as a society.



posted by: irishred (reply)
post date: 10.18.06 (12:16 pm)

This is what America has become. Litigation has changed our society beyond comprehension. This country continues its slide into the abyss of ridiculosity (my new word.)



posted by: lorischuster (reply)
post date: 10.18.06 (5:12 pm)

What's different is not that kids get hurt...but that parents feel the need to sue. What in the hell is wrong with people? I'm not going to even get started because I'll end up writing a novella and popping a blood vessel. Besides...Irish said it best...pure ridiculosity.



posted by: Bloggers Home Page (reply)
post date: 10.18.06 (5:28 pm)

Thanks for your blog on Bloggers Home Page. Please recommend us to any other bloggers who might be interested. Best regards.



posted by: sebastianjoshua (reply)
post date: 10.18.06 (5:57 pm)

errr... kids, what do u expect. definately in their mind is playground. injuries can happen even u are really have a tight supervision.
NO PLAYGROUND means no future as kids cannot develop creativeness.
PLEASE blame on parents as they WANT the best but dont know anything.



posted by: tfruge1 (reply)
post date: 10.19.06 (8:42 am)

Reply to: LadyG
I would have to agree with you. It really is a shame. Everyone is too quick to sue everybody because no one wants to take responsibility for their own actions.



posted by: Chuba (reply)
post date: 10.20.06 (7:20 am)

I agree about the parents being to blame. Parents are entirely too quick to sue and cause trouble when it comes to their "precious babies." When I was in middle school we all had our little games. Some guys would play touch football and some would play basketball. I feel the teachers need to take some responsibility too. When the guys would play ball, the teachers would supervise and when it got too rough she would put an end to the game. I wonder what the schools are going to ban next? Basketball can be just as rough. I've seen kids get broken noses from playing basketball all b/c an elbow was flung up the wrong way. How about simply running around the play ground? Kids are clumsy, I know I was. When I was little, I was running and tripped on something and scrapped my arm up. Where will the banning end. Kids already hate school; this is the little part of the day they look forward to, besides lunch. That's it, pack them in with nasty unhealthy food then take away the exercise. And people wonder why kids are all obese.

Your Name:


Your Comment:


Liberal Center

Democratic National Committee



Political Party Beliefs
Democratic Party
Republican Party
Green Party
Libertarian Party


Know Your Candidates
Joseph Biden (D)
Hillary R Clinton (D)
John Edwards (D)
Russell Feingold (D)
Bill Frist (R)
Newt Gingrich (R)
Rudy Giuliani (R)
Al Gore (D)
Lindsey Graham (R)
Ted Kennedy (D)
John Kerry (D)
John McCain (R)
Barack Obama (D)


Political Podcasts
DNC Podcast
Left, Right & Center
Face The Nation
CNN Podcast
NY Times Podcast
NPR: It's All Politics
Baton Rouge News Podcasts


DNC

Blue Donkey

Vote Democrat

The Donkey Wins!

The New York Times

Louisiana State University